NFL Confidence Pool Rules: A Rulebook You Can Copy
Confidence pool rules start with one idea: you pick the winner of every game, then rank your picks by how sure you are. With 16 games, your surest pick is worth 16 points and your shakiest is worth 1, and each number is used once. A correct pick earns the points you gave it, a wrong pick earns nothing, and the highest total wins the week.
That covers the scoring. A complete rulebook also has to answer what happens in bye weeks, tied games, missed picks, and postponed or canceled games. This guide sets out the standard NFL confidence pool rules, explains each one, and ends with a version you can copy. For help ranking your own picks, see NFL confidence pool strategy.
What are the basic confidence pool rules?
- Pick every game. Each week, pick a winner in every NFL game on the schedule.
- Assign confidence points. Rank your picks from the number of games that week down to 1. Each number is used exactly once.
- Score correct picks. A correct pick earns its confidence number. A wrong pick earns zero.
- Picks lock at kickoff. Once a game starts, its pick and its confidence number are final.
- Weekly and season standings. The highest total wins the week. Points also add up across the season.
- A tiebreaker settles ties. Usually a guess at the total points in the Monday night game.
The sections below explain each rule and the common alternatives.
How do confidence points work in bye weeks?
The point scale matches the number of games that week. A full week of 16 games uses 16 to 1. A bye week with 14 games uses 14 to 1. Because the top of the scale changes, weekly totals are not directly comparable across weeks, but that is fine: every player in the pool has the same scale in the same week.
Some pools prefer a fixed scale every week, for example always 16 to 1, with the unused top numbers simply not available in bye weeks. Either rule works if everyone uses it.
Are confidence pools straight up or against the spread?
Straight up is the default: pick the team you think will win. Some pools score against the spread instead, which makes each game closer to a coin flip and changes how players assign points. Decide one way for the whole season. The trade-offs are in against the spread versus straight up.
Do wrong picks lose points in a confidence pool?
In standard confidence pool rules, no. A wrong pick scores zero. Some pools add a penalty: a wrong pick loses the points assigned to it, so a wrong 16 costs 16. That makes the top of the scale a real risk and rewards players who are careful with their big numbers. It also produces negative weeks, which some casual groups dislike.
Another optional rule awards double points for a correct pick on an underdog. Both of these are settings on the Rules tab in Pocket Office Pool: Incorrect picks subtract points and Correct underdog picks score double. Leave both off for a standard pool.
What happens if an NFL game ends in a tie?
Ties are rare. From 2016 through 2025, only 10 of 2,639 regular-season NFL games ended tied. They still need a rule, because a tied game was carrying someone’s 16.
Most confidence pools score a tie as zero for everyone, since nobody picked the winner. A few award each player half of the confidence points they assigned. Zero is simpler and is the more common rule.
What happens if a game is postponed or canceled?
This is the rule most pools forget to write until they need it. NFL games have been moved for weather, for public health reasons in 2020, and in Week 17 of 2022 the Bills and Bengals game was canceled after Damar Hamlin’s cardiac arrest on the field and was never completed.
A postponed game that is still played keeps its pick and its points. It counts toward the week it was originally scheduled in, even if it is played days later. The weekly winner is simply announced late.
A game that is canceled and never played needs one of three rules:
- Void the game. It scores zero for everyone. This is the most common rule. Players who put a high number on it lose those points, but so does anyone else who did.
- Award the points to everyone. Each player gets the confidence points they assigned to that game, as if every pick were correct.
- Rescale the week. Remove the game and recalculate each player’s score as if the canceled game had never been on the slate. This is the fairest rule and the most work.
Bowl season raises the same question, covered in our college bowl confidence pool guide. Pick one now and put it in your rulebook. It is easier to agree on a rule in August than in the middle of a week when someone’s 16 is at stake.
What happens if a player forgets to submit picks?
A missing pick scores zero. If a player submits winners but forgets to assign confidence numbers, the simplest rule is to treat the week as missed. Avoid automatic picks on a player’s behalf. They lead to arguments about which team should have been chosen and what number it deserved.
What is the tiebreaker in a confidence pool?
The standard tiebreaker is a guess at the combined final score of the last game of the week, usually Monday night. The closest guess wins. Decide whether the closest guess wins outright or the closest guess without going over. Pocket Office Pool supports both, and also supports margin of victory as the question. All the options are in the football pool tiebreaker rules guide.
An NFL confidence pool rulebook you can copy
[Pool name] NFL Confidence Pool Rules, 2026 season
1. Picks. Pick the winner of every game each week, [straight up / against the spread].
2. Confidence points. Rank your picks from the number of games that week down to 1. Each number is used once.
3. Scoring. A correct pick earns its confidence number. Wrong and missing picks score [zero / minus their confidence number]. Tied games score zero for everyone.
4. Deadline. Each pick locks at that game’s kickoff.
5. Postponed and canceled games. A postponed game counts in its original week. A canceled game [scores zero for everyone].
6. Weekly winner. Highest point total. Ties go to the closest guess at the total points in the [Monday night] game, [closest without going over].
7. Season winner. Highest point total over Weeks 1 to 18.
8. Entry and payout. [Entry amount], due by [date]. Payout: [weekly prize and season split].
Running a confidence pool online
Hand-scoring a confidence pool is slow, because every pick has a different value. On Pocket Office Pool, players make and rank their picks on one pick sheet, scoring is automatic, and the weekly and season standings update after each game. Setup details are on the NFL confidence pool page. Still deciding on a format? Compare confidence pools and pick’em.
When you are ready, create your confidence pool. The first 4 seats are free, then it is $3 per player beyond the free 4.
Frequently asked questions
What are the rules of a confidence pool?
Pick the winner of every game each week and rank your picks by confidence, from the number of games down to 1, using each number once. A correct pick earns the points you assigned it and a wrong pick earns zero. The highest weekly total wins, and a tiebreaker on the Monday night game settles ties.
How many confidence points are there in a week?
One for each game. A 16-game week uses 16 down to 1. A bye week with 14 games uses 14 down to 1, unless the pool uses a fixed scale every week.
Do you lose points for a wrong pick in a confidence pool?
Not in a standard pool. A wrong pick scores zero. Some pools subtract the confidence points of a wrong pick to make the top numbers riskier.
What happens in a confidence pool if a game is canceled?
Most pools void the game so it scores zero for everyone. Others award every player the points they assigned to it, or rescale the week as if the game had not been scheduled. A postponed game that is still played counts in its original week.
What happens if an NFL game ends in a tie in a confidence pool?
Most pools score a tie as zero for every player. Ties are rare: 10 of 2,639 regular-season games from 2016 to 2025.